Categories
Best Of live music

Best of 2025: Live Music

In a world that felt even more on fire than usual – by which I mostly mean the fire was closer to me personally – I found a lot to be grateful for: my friends, my partner, my family, my jobs. My most often source for solace was, as it has been since I was a teenager, live music.

Across nine cities, I saw about 150 shows (expect that to be fewer next year; I’m trying to be more intentional and include more deliberate days of rest each week). Unsurprisingly, Dick’s Den was at the top of my list, hitting an average of once every two weeks, with Natalie’s Grandview and Cafe Bourbon Street tied for second place at 12, and Ace and Rumba also tied at 7. Interestingly, the Columbus Museum of Art and the Wex tied at 4 each, and all of which were terrific. Because there was so much good stuff, I interpreted “Festival” a little more liberally, as anything with multiple stages or days.

No way of knowing what’s next, but there are already some shows I’m very excited for in the upcoming year, and choosing to set my eyes with hope rather than leap to despondency.

All photos are by me, everything is in Columbus unless stated otherwise, and the listings are in chronological order

Joy Oladokun at Newport Music Hall

Top 25(ish) Shows

  • Joy Oladokun (Newport Music Hall, 01/21/2025) – Not quite the first show of the year I saw, or even exactly the first touring show (John Calvin Abney, who had a banner this year supporting SG Goodman as well as putting out a stellar EP, did a joint show with Lydia Loveless at Secret Studio a little earlier), but in many ways finally getting to see Joy Oladokun after being a massive fan of her last two records in the room that held so many of my favorite shows of all time (Wilco, Morphine, The Cramps, Sonic Youth, Medeski Martin and Wood/Chocolate Genius, X/The Detroit Cobras) set the tone perfectly and gave me a shot of burning resolve right after the inauguration. I thought the mix of solo acoustic and full-band numbers highlighted both sides of her work in a way I’ve seen a lot of singer-songwriters try but very rarely pull off anywhere nearly as well, and made some of the textures – revealing a surprising (to me) contextual thread between her Observations From a Crowded Room and Don Henley’s Building a Perfect Beast – appear in greater detail and relief.
  • Chuck Prophet and his Cumbia Shoes (Natalie’s Grandview, 02/05/2025) – I’ve never seen a bad Chuck Prophet show – the rare universally acclaimed songwriter who’s every bit as powerful a bandleader – but this flourishing of his merging a couple of members of his longstanding unit Mission Express with Cali cumbia band ¿Qiensave? into Cumbia Shoes hit another level of powerful catharsis, nuance, and unbridled fun.
Chuck Prophet and his Cumbia Shoes at Natalie’s Grandview
  • Joel Ross’s Good Vibes (Wexner Center for the Arts)/Joel Harrison’s Anthems of Unity (Natalie’s Grandview), both 03/06/2025 – Talking to a good friend and stalwart of the NYC and, now, LA, jazz scene about how the touring climate was in town, I brought up this particular evening when I got to see the first set of vibes maestro Joel Ross’s crushing current Sextet (that interplay of Maria Grand on alto and Josh Johnson on tenor in the frontline seared my eyebrows off), an unbroken suite of music blending Ross’s originals and standards that turned my head around then drive 10 minutes and see the astonishing guitarist Joel Harrison do his Anthems of Unity book with two of our local heroes, organist Tony Monaco and drummerr Louis Tsamous. These two approaches to jazz/improvised music/the history of American music, and the way both of these artists approached the canon and the way music can be about the rest of the world instead of being hermetic or closed reverberated hard against each other in my chest.
  • Deli Girls with Deionyx (Cafe Bourbon Street, 04/04/2025) – Over the last couple of years, Bobo has reclaimed the throne as my favorite place to see noisy, edgier rock and roll and one of my favorite places to see more underground-leaning DJs. This show scratched both of those itches hard and deep – NYC’s Deli Girls’ mix of grinding, throbbing rave beats, acid-singed noise, and in-your-face punk and Deionyx’s bleeding edge soulful-at-an-angle set of surprising and powerful records both made my heart incredibly full, as did the room packed full of people 15-25 years younger than I am.
Deli Girls at Cafe Bourbon Street
  • Greater Columbus Community Orchestra with Brian Harnetty, The Visitor (Hilliard Presbyterian Church, 04/06/2025) – Banner year for composer Brian Harnetty, who released a remarkable memoir, Noisy Memory, and put out a gorgeous recording of string quartet and samples The House, and a visual installation This Was Once a Forest, This Was Once a Sea, as well as premiering this rich, sparkling brass ensemble piece with the Greater Columbus Community Orchestra that I’m still feeling vibrate through me.
  • Nikhil P. Yerwadekar and Living Language (Barbes, NYC, 04/11/2025) – Because the sole New York trip this year was to celebrate my 45th birthday with a gang of my favorite people in the world, there were fewer distinct cultural items on the calendar. But this was an extreme highlight: Yerwadekar, whom I last saw backing Hailu Mergia at a Big Ears, leading a ferocious band through Afrobeat classics and originals in a wall-to-wall-packed Barbes back room where no one stopped moving. Made even sweeter as my great friend Andrew Patton’s inaugural visit to one of my temples of music.
Nikhil P. Yerwadekar and Living Language at Barbes
  • The Lilybandits with Two Cow Garage (Natalie’s Grandview, 06/05/2025) – I think anyone who’s read ten lines I’ve written or spent ten minutes in my presence knows I think Todd May’s the greatest songwriter Columbus has ever produced. They culminated an important reissue project of his first mature band, The Lilybandits with At Thirty Three and a Third this year, and lost its drummer and their lifelong friend Keith Smith last year. This extremely rare reunion of the original core members (May, Trent Arnold, Jose Gonzalez, Bob Hite) with longtime friend Keith Hanlon filing in on drums, Bob Ray Starker providing the horn lines he gifted them with on those records, and Smith’s son joining on a few vocals, was probably the biggest reminder of how much I love my town all year, wrapped up in a rock show that made hard to believe they’d only gotten together to run through the songs once. Two Cow Garage, long influenced by the Lilybandits (the first time I ever saw Two Cow, they did a Todd May song and dedicated it to “The genius of Bernie’s”) set the tone with a set of jubilant catharsis.
  • Charles “Wigg” Walker (ACME Feed and Seed, Nashville, 06/14/2025) – My eyebrows shot up when I saw Charles Walker – who I knew from his days with the Dynamites (who the Funkdefy collective, at the time including the above-mentioned Andrew Patton, booked in Columbus more than once, and my great friends in St Louis, at the time including fellow Columbus legend Matt Benz booked at Twangfest – was doing a regular brunch gig when Anne and I already planned to be in Nashville. We juggled our schedule to make sure we were in town in time for this and stayed for two sets: Walker still in perfect voice, backed by a sizzling organ trio led by his longtime Dynamites foil Charles Treadway, going through stone soul classics and gorgeous new originals.
Lilybandits at Natalie’s Grandview
  • Dan Baird and Homemade Sin (Eastside Bowl, Nashville, 06/14/2025) – If the only thing this show gave us was the five minutes of Dan Baird and his killer band opening with the Open All Night highlight “Sheila,” with Baird’s grin and electric presence, it would have justified the six-hours drive each way, the hotel cost, all of it. But it gave us so much more. 45 minutes of blistering rock and roll, led by someone who, at 71, is outplaying and dancing rockers a third of his age. Also, this was a beautiful look in the way other scenes take care of their own, organized by Warner Hodges (Baird’s guitar foil in Homemade Sin, longtime lead player in Jason and the Scorchers), here leading his own band and sitting in with every other set in a benefit for his former Scorchers bandmate Jeff Johnson.
  • Sam Johnson and Noah Demland, Contrary Motion (Wild Goose Creative, 06/20/2025) – The second or third year in what I hope continues as a series exploring the history of Queer chamber music/new music featured new originals from organizers Sam Johnson and Noah Demland, classics of the canon from Pauline Oliveros and John Cage, and contemporary pieces from Caroline Shaw and Leilahua Lanzilotti by a tight ensemble of some of our best players. A brilliant glimpse of where this music is, how it got here, and how relevant it still is.
  • Say She She (Woodlands Tavern, 06/20/2025) – Finally got to see my favorite of the current neo-disco bands, NYC’s Say She She, and they tore the roof off Woodlands in a crowd full of people I mostly didn’t know (besides Anne and my Providence-based friend Daria, maybe we knew two other people in a nearly sold out room) all dancing in a sweaty, delirious mess. The reason I went from the show above to this show, but they got separate listings, is that they felt like very distinct events to me; they didn’t resonate against one another like the couple of shared line items.
Say She She at Woodlands
  • Budos Band with Benny Trokan (Woodward Theatre, Cincinnati, 07/15/2025) – One of the great live bands I’ve seen in 30 years of seeing live music, Budos Band, retained their crown on a gorgeous summer night in a venue I hadn’t made it to in Cincinnati previously. Icing on the cake was Benny Trokan – who Anne introduced me to in his days with Robbers on High Street – with a tight, swinging four-piece going through the lovely smooth soul of his recent solo record.
  • Mike Dillon’s Punkadelick (Dick’s Den, 07/18/2025) – Columbus is lucky to get percussionist Mike Dillon coming through our fair city a decent amount, but what made this show special was the presence of New Orleans drummer Nikki Glaspie, who’s shared the stage with Beyonce, Ivan Neville, Snarky Puppy, and Nth Power. That powerhouse sense of the multiplicity of groove and the emotional content of the song took both sets I stayed for into outer space.
Budos Band at Woodward Theatre, Cincinnati
  • Vandoliers (Rumba Cafe, 08/12/2025) – I’d been a fan of the Vandoliers since their 2019 breakthrough Forever and this year’s Life Behind Bars was a revelation: simultaneously a reminder of what drove me so crazy about the alt.country/Americana scene in my teens and 20s and a broadening in the same sense as their Dallas forebears’ Old 97s’ Fight Songs and Satellite Rides. Similarly, this show was a gleeful, textured statement of purpose, with lead singer Jenni Rose’s songs detailing her coming out the other side of addiction and gender dysmorphia into a brighter place without sugarcoating any of the challenges, and the band – with one exception – having been with her the entire ride and still shouting together. As Anne said, “This is what all protest music should sound like: a party that also makes you want to smash shit.”
  • Mark Lomax II (Streetlight Guild, 08/28/2025) – I was lucky to see a few examples of one of our finest composers and drummers, Mark Lomax, in action this year, including a reunion with Scott Woods and his trio, and also missed a big premiere at the Wexner Center because I lost track of my schedule and didn’t buy before it sold out. But this rare solo drum recital, directly inspired by Tiffany Lawson’s What If I Told You It Was Freedom (look for more on that in my Art Exhibits Best Of) in Streetlight Guild’s smaller upstairs gallery space was a direct injection into my veins of his compositional strategies, his fingerprint-distinct approach to the drums, and about creativity in general as he discussed the pieces and personal history with Lawson and Woods.
Mark Lomax II at Streetlight Guild
  • Etienne Charles and Creole Soul (Wexner Center for the Arts) and Quintron and Ms. Pussycat with DANA (Cafe Bourbon Street), both 09/18/2025 – Two approaches to blending cultures and styles through a distinct lens of a life in art, both made exciting shows on this September night. Trumpeter/composer Etienne Charles led his phenomenal band through a selection of compositions drawing from jazz and funk traditions and his Trinidadian heritage to a rapturous crowd at the Wexner Center Performance space. A five minute drive away – we sadly missed Mutha Funk though I heard great things – Quintron and Ms. Pussycat celebrated their 30th anniversary as a rock-and-roll puppet show with homemade drum machines, greasy organ, and garage-rock hooks that’s had me in its hooks for decades and is still a show like nothing else and one I’ll never miss if I can help it.
  • Kid Congo Powers with Cheater Slicks (Grog Shop, Cleveland, 09/20/2025) – I did a lot of thinking about memory this year – I often do, but at 45 it felt pronounced – and seeing the great Kid Congo, a throughline of so much music I loved play a set bursting with memories of friends and colleagues he’d lost, including “The Boy Had It All,” “Sean DeLear,” “La araña,” “He Walked In,” and songs he’d played with bands many of whose members have slo passed on like The Cramps and The Gun Club, vibrated with those feelings and reminded me that you can carry those people with you in a jubilant way without diminishing how much it hurts. In addition, Cheater Slicks (longtime friends and mutual admirers of Powers) who have been on a streak the last two years, played one of the best sets I’ve seen them do in 30 years of seeing them semi-regularly.
  • Lorette Velvette with Deerfrance (Bar DKDC, Memphis, 09/26/2025) – The best musical side quest we’ve had in over a decade of going to Memphis with Gonerfest as the main course: Panther Burns legend Lorette Velvette on a double-bill with linchpin of John Cale’s Sabotage era Deerfrance in the intimate confines of Bar DKDC. Killing new songs from both artists, excellent bands including members of the Reigning Sound, Panther Burns, and the Memphis Symphony, and a gorgeous clinic of song.
Lorette Velvette at Bar DKDC, Memphis
  • Talisha Holmes and the Stardust (Dick’s Den, 10/03/2025) – I’ve been a fan of Talisha Holmes’ voice since High School and her singing and repertoire for almost 20 years, but the first show with the band she dubbed Stardust felt like a new chapter opening with ecstatic/spiritual jazz and folk textures into the thorny, dense R&B she does better than anyone else in town. It was an eye opening evening that got me extremely excited to see what’s coming next.
  • DANA with Messrs and DJ Adam Scoppa (Ace of Cups, 10/17/2025) – As seen in my records of the year, I thought DANA’s Clean Living was a triumph, and their constant touring schedule honed their most nuanced and powerful set of songs into a ferocious live set. Here, along with a rare reunion set from Columbus’ deconstructed hardcore heroes Messrs (including drummer Mat Bisaro playing like a monster while also going through a grueling round of chemo) and the sweet sounds of Adam Scopp’s Heatwave dance night made one of the most satisfying reminders of what I love about Columbus.
DANA at Ace of Cups
  • Robbie Fulks (Natalie’s Grandview, 10/18/2025) – Robbie Fulks is another artist who is no stranger to anyone who’s read this or talked to me, but what made this appearance at Natalie’s special to me was a return to the four-piece rock band format that made me fall hard in the first place, with drummer Gerald Dowd, bassist KC McDonough, and guitarist Robbie Gjersoe doing a setlist that returned to the first three records – and the excellent new one, Now Then – with one highlight after another.
  • Micah Schnabel and Vanessa Jean Speckman (Rumba Cafe, 10/23/2025) – A valedictory show for two artists who have done so much for Columbus in their performance home, Rumba, and a set that made my heart almost burst out of my chest.
Micah Schnabel and Vanessa Jean Speckman at Rumba Cafe
  • Worthington Chamber Orchestra, Frontiers of Sound (Worthington United Methodist Church, 11/07/2025) – The Worthington Chamber Orchestra has a great series, and they continued to cement their place in the creative firmament of Columbus with commissioning the first violin concerto from Columbus native (now based in New York) Aaron Quinn, played by Devin Copfer (WCO concertmaster, Chamber Brews co-founder, Devi and Liz, Urban Art Ensemble) and the orchestra. The piece planted its flag in a truly American continuum, textures that felt like Ives and Copland, cascading harmonies that recalled some of the sticky synth layers of vintage Detroit techno, and a soulful bluesiness in the central violin line that still had all rigor you’d want to see from classical music.
  • Durand Jones and the Indications with Psycodelics (Newport Music Hall, 11/09/2025) – The smooth soul of Durand Jones had a packed crowd at the Newport eating out of their palms with a sweaty, vibrant show that summed up what so many of us love about the genre while also serving as the entry point for so many younger people. Psycodelics did a muscular, fiery take on vintage sounds like EWF, Sly, and P-Funk that reminded me that music has a long future ahead of it.
  • Minibeast (Cafe Bourbon Street, 11/14/2025) – Peter Prescott’s Minibeast knocked me completely over, with sparking noise and 10,000-league-deep grooves. Also a reminder of how good Bobo sounds these days. Every nuance of that powerful, multifaceted sound washed over everyone in the room.
Vandoliers at Rumba Cafe

Top 20 Festival Sets

Ugly Stick at Natalie’s Grandview
  • Beachland’s 25th Anniversary (Beachland Ballroom and Tavern, Cleveland)
    • Mourning [A] BLKStar
    • Pull Chains
Mourning [A] BLKStar at Beachland Ballroom
  • Lost Weekend Records’ 22nd Anniversary (Natalie’s Grandview)
    • Ugly Stick
    • Thomas Jefferson Slave Apartments Featuring Mickey Mocnik
TJSA with Mickey Mocnik at Natalie’s Grandview
  • Big Ears Festival (Various Venues, Knoxville)
    • Kate Soper and Wet Ink Ensemble, Ipsa Dixit (Bijou Theatre)
    • Joy Guidry (The Point)
    • Tyshawn Sorey and DACAMERA, Monochromatic Light (Afterlife) (St. John’s)
Kate Soper and Wet Ink Ensemble, Big Ears
  • Lee Bains III and Lonnie Holley (Barley’s)
  • King Britt/Tyshawn Sorey/Meshell Ndegeocello/Melz (Jackson Terminal)
  • SML (The Standard)
King Britt/Tyshawn Sorey/Meshell Ndegeocello/MELZ at Big Ears
  • Future Salad Days Opening (Blockfort Parking Lot)
    • Juanita and Juan
    • Clickbait
    • Cheater Slicks
Juanita and Juan at Future Salad Days
  • Jazz and Ribs Fest
    • Ron Holmes’ Eclecticism
Ron Holmes Eclecticism, Jazz and Ribs Fest
  • Gonerfest (Wiseacre Brewing, Memphis)
    • Pylon Reenactment Society
    • Lightning Bolt
    • Lothario
    • Cheap Fix
    • Des Demonas
    • TINA!!!
Des Demonas, Gonerfest
Categories
Best Of Playlist record reviews

Best of 2024 – Songs

As I have the last few years, these podcasts are expansions of my favorite albums of the year; songs that wouldn’t let me go or representations of albums that I loved but didn’t quite make my top 20. These are – mostly – songs with words and creating a concentrating emotion or image; as opposed to the companion playlist, Spaces, which are – usually instrumental and create a landscape or a vibration for me.

In a broad sense – you’re used to this if you’ve been reading me for a little while – this starts with some anthems and ends with some prayers, through my crooked eye, of course. Your mileage may – and probably should – vary.

  • Miko Marks, “I’ll Cry For Yours (Will You Cry For Mine)” – The last few years have given us a bounty of tribute records that expand and subvert the sometimes perfunctory nature of these collections and My Black Country: The Songs of Alice Randall is one of the best I’ve ever heard. Assembled to go along with Randall’s terrific memoir of the same name, this pioneering black country artist’s work gets fresh, loving treatments. There isn’t a dud in its entire length, but probably my favorite is this searing, explosive read on a Randall tune I didn’t previously know, originally recorded by ’90s country singer Tamra Rosanes. Up until literally the night before I started writing this, I was sure I was kicking the playlist off with the next song, off my favorite record of the year, but walking under a fragile snow through the empty streets of my neighborhood, this song (which had been steadily moving toward the pole position of the playlist) said, “No, dumbass, this is the tone of the year and the tone of the music that spoke to you it’s all in there, between Miko Marks’ voice and those horns.” “Our wounds will heal through tears and time. When they draw up sides, can you cross that line?”
  • Hurray for the Riff Raff, “Snake Plant (The Past Is Still Alive)” – From the moment I heard it, Hurray for the Riff Raff’s The Past Is Still Alive felt like their masterpiece (so far), one of the best singer-songwriter records I’ve ever heard, and my record of the year. I had to play the whole thing back as soon as it ended. Every song on this record is perfect – arrangements pop, their voice has never sounded better – but this was the single song I reached for most often when I was down, and it’s a spectacular example of Segarra’s ability to stitch together perfectly captured moments with direct address and craft a mammoth dagger planted squarely in the heart. “Tattoo with a needle and thread, most of our old friends are dead. So test your drugs, remember Narcan; there’s a war on the people, what don’t you understand?”
  • Chuck Prophet, “Wake The Dead” – Long one of my favorite songwriters, Chuck Prophet refreshed his sound with an album-length collaboration with Salinas cumbia band Qiansave. That album – of which this is the title track – is the loosest, most powerful album Prophet’s made in a while; the sharply observed lyrics and his supple voice slide beautifully through these rhythms, both illuminating the shadowy spaces of the other. “If they ask you any questions, go ahead and tell the truth; if we have to, we can plead insanity. If it’s good enough for you, it works for me.”
  • Tim Easton, “Everything You’re Afraid Of” – My first favorite Columbus songwriter – based in Nashville for many years – put out his best record in years with the loose, ragged-and-right Find Your Way and this was the centerpiece in my mind, another song that gave me so much solace over the year I can barely sum it up (though I certainly tried when he did it at Dick’s Den this year and I was a bawling mess). “Ask yourself how you can help someone else who’s in pain today. Take all those worries, put ’em in a big ol’ book; leave the book on a stranger’s shelf. Now, congratulate yourself. Send a meaningful prayer of sympathy to all your enemies.”
  • Sinkane featuring Tru Osborne, “Everything is Everything” – Another of my favorite Columbus exports to the world, Sinkane made another spectacular record with We Belong, ornate but loose, dancefloor grooves sprinkled with interesting arrangement choices and beguiling melodies. With a vocal assist from Tru Osborne, this song is another in his long line of quintessential summertime jams alongside “Runnin'” and “Here We Be.” “That’s the problem with tomorrow; always one day away. I want to be free in this moment; well, this is what I pray.”
  • Ledisi, “Stay Here Tonight” – I loved Ledisi’s detour into the work of Nina Simone, but her new record of originals, Good Life, was exactly what I needed – like sinking into a bubble bath with a perfectly cold martini at the side; like the first time you hear Coltrane’s Crescent. The gleaming crystal keyboard line over crunchy drums, around her swooping voice blend beautifully. “Let’s be clear – you gotta say it right now: is it true?”
  • Adeem the Artist, “Wounded Astronaut” – Knoxville breakout Americana star Adeem the Artist followed their astonishing White Trash Revelry with the knottier, denser Anniversary that took a little longer to reveal its pleasures but hit me even deeper. This biting, deceptively easy-going look at the way we men treat women knocked me sideways – ripping a scab off rarely comes with as catchy a sing-along chorus as this. “Oh, the women I have loved and left injured in the shadows of my childhood dysfunctions playing out in real time… Were that I was younger, I could have put to use my wonder to imagine better ways a healthy partner is defined.”
  • The Paranoid Style, “Print the Legend” – Literary rock band The Paranoid Style, led by married couple Elizabeth Nelson and Timothy Bracy, put out their best record yet this year The Interrogator, making excellent use of Peter Holsapple (The dBs, Continental Drifters) and this catchy barbed wire-tumbleweed was one of my favorite songs of the year; an alternate universe urban “The Road Goes On Forever” that questions if there was ever a party in the first place. “Jill Collins grabbed the bag and then she grabbed the wheel. Sidney was shot, and near-passed-out, when he made his last appeal: ‘Keep me safe and keep me alive, and I’ll settle the score.’ They held hands and they laid eyes, before she pushed him out the door.”
  • Brittany Howard, “What Now” – With Howard’s sophomore solo outing she made a hard-hitting record every bit the equal of the Alabama Shakes work I initially fell in love with. The swinging drive of the groove here underpins the barely restrained rage of the lyric and vocal in an intoxicating way. “If you want someone to hate, then bring it on me.”
  • Joshua Ray Walker, “Thank You For Listening” – One of the finest new honky tonk singers, Joshua Ray Walker, in the midst of a fight with colon cancer, put out a gorgeous record of stripped down, acoustic takes on many of his finest songs and this lone new tune is one of his best, a four a.m. whisper of gratitude and reminder why any of us make things. “Thanks for listening to all my sad songs. Thanks for loving me when I sing the words wrong. Makes the bad times not seem so long.”
  • Hilary Gardner, “Jingle Jangle Jingle (I Got Spurs)” – I got to see one of my favorite jazz singers Hilary Gardner’s new project with the Lonesome Pines at Mezzrow around last year’s Winter Jazz Fest, and I liked it – I’d love hearing Gardner sing the phone book – but I was a little disappointed it was more movie-cowboy songs than the Western Swing I’d hoped for. Getting to live with the record, On The Trail With the Lonesome Pines, I love it. This Lilley and Loesser tune – which I first knew from Popeye as a kid, but was a focal point of a Tex Ritter Best Of I wore out in my 20s – sums up everything I love about her witty, winsome approach to these songs and the interplay with this crack band, especially the vocal nudges from guitarist Justin Poindexter. “Oh, Bessie Lou, though we’ve done a heap of dreaming, this is why it won’t come true: I’ve got spurs that jingle jangle jingle as I go riding merrily along. And they sing, ‘Oh, ain’t you glad you’re single?’ and that song ain’t so very far from wrong.”
  • Brittney Spencer, “Desperate” – One of my favorite new country singers exploded with a phenomenal front-to-back debut record My Stupid Life, and as much as I loved the first single “Night In,” this song got its hooks in me – with sharply detailed production that shows every nuance of Spencer’s voice and a bolt-from-the-blue pedal steel line around immediately relatable but never stupid lyrics, and a fist-pumping chorus about ambiguity and anxiety; a combination I’m always a sucker for. “I’m so used to hiding from the whole truth; caught between the holding back and worrying how you’ll react.”
  • Aoife O’Donovan and The Knights, “All My Friends” – Aoife O’Donovan continues to stun me, and this title track on her album-length collaboration with chamber orchestra The Knights, is an addition to her canon of some of the best songs written by anyone of my generation. The use of the orchestra – and horns from brass quartet The Westerlies – gives me chills every time I play it, while her voice and the lyrics give me hope through tears. “I always knew, and so did you, that we were going to war. Now years have passed; I’m trying to remember who it is for. If we reach 36 or if the door gets slammed, at least I know we’ve tried for all my friends.”
  • Waxahatchee, “The Wolves” – Waxahatchee keeps trumping herself and Tigers Blood is another triumph with warm, sharply observed songs; maps for living in the world in dusky, luminous production and sparse arrangements. “You’ve been proving yourself wrong with or without me here. You don’t look around, you don’t check the score; you cause all that trouble, then you beg for more on every warm horizon of what I let disappear.”
  • Adrienne Lenker, “Sadness As A Gift” – I like but don’t love the band Big Thief, so it took multiple conversations around the Big Ears Festival about their lead singer Lenker’s set being the favorite set of one person after another to get me to check out her gorgeous solo record Bright Futures. The violin-drenched arrangement here sets a perfect tone for the steely resignation of the song and her voice way up front and bright with I think two male voices hovering around it like moths. A perfect song in a damn fine album. “Just leaning on the windowsill. You could write me someday, and I hope you will. You could see the sadness as a gift, and still, the seasons go so fast.”
  • Sierra Ferrell, “Dollar Bill Bar” – This was Sierra Ferrell’s year, breaking out to bigger venues and capturing the ears of a wider range of people than my crowd of roots rock weirdos, and it’s incredibly well-deserved. She blends and braids the various strains of American music into personal, relatable songs as well as anyone working today; the arrangement on this with a moaning, sarcastic harmonica and a jaunty shuffle on the drums, is a perfect example. “If I had a dollar for every single hopeful heart, well, honey, I could break a hundred down at the dollar bill bar.”
  • Sarah Shook and the Disarmers, “Backsliders” – River Shook and their band continued expanding on the variety of textures and rhythms that made Nightroamer such a delightful jumping off point with Revelations but make some space for the vintage honky tonk shitkicking numbers that they write better than anybody else, like this mournful morning-after statement of purpose. “Now I got one foot out the door and you’re still getting dressed. Hate that I can’t say no as easily as you say yes. I’m a real piece of shit and you’re a vixen in a dress. I thought we was movin’ on but I was wrong I guess.”
  • Kyshona, “Where My Mind Goes” – Kyshona made my favorite of her records so far with Legacy, like the last couple of songs taking on the history of American music with open arms but also her family history and the legacy of black music. This gripping, dark gospel stomp sums up much of what I love about this record. “Where my mind goes when you tell me that I just can’t carry on. It’s where my mind goes – you can’t stop me. I’ll keep moving on.”
  • N’shai Iman, “Can’t Take It” – I discovered rising Columbus singer-songwriter N’shai Iman this year and this song enraptured me, some of the finest alternative R&B or is that just the mainstream of R&B these days, I’ve heard in a long time with a subdued under-my-skin groove and a stunning vocal. “I can’t feel your touch from so far away; I need hands-on assistance.”
  • Meshell Ndegeocello, “Another Country” – Meshell Ndegeocello’s No More Water: The Gospel of James Baldwin pulls off the brilliant magic act of simultaneously exulting Baldwin and taking him off the pedestal and out of the box that tries to make one of the great literary minds simple and digestible. This soaring song bursts from distorted spoken word into a chiaroscuro sunrise. Beautiful. “Gold brown red brown, more greed grows inside. Make more love, never grief.”
  • Arooj Aftab, “Whiskey” – I loved Arooj Aftab’s earlier records, especially Vulture Prince and the collaborative Love in Exile, but even as a fan I was unprepared for the stunning Night Reign. This contemporary torch song blends the guitarist of Gyan Riley and Kaki King with Maeve Gilchrist’s harp, Jamey Haddad’s percussion, and Linda May Han Oh’s bass into a rich landscape for Aftab’s vocal to flow through. “We’ll fade into the night on waves of your perfume. I’m drunk, and you’re insane; tell me how we will get home.”
  • John Moreland, “Visitor” – John Moreland, one of my favorite songwriters in the Guy Clark or Elizabeth Bishop tradition of turning a situation around and seeing how the light hits it from all sides, made another perfect record this year. This title track is a hymn to finding ways to live with one another, with a circling organ over subtly grimy drums. “I’ve been stoned and scared of my reflection. I can see your shifty smirk from the depths of my depression, but I will not be your puppet or your payment, your easy entertainment, for I’ve made amends for me.”
  • Rapsody featuring Erykah Badu, “3:AM” – Rapsody’s Please Don’t Cry knocked me over, front-to-back, but this sleepy slow jam produced by Lonestarmusik, S1, and Jemarcus Bridges, thick with lazy horns and an instant-classic Badu hook was an early favorite track of mine and still beguiles me. “I loved to laugh with you – you were never my mistake; a blessing.”
  • Lucky Daye, “Top” – Maybe my favorite straight-down-the-line R&B record of the year, Lucky Daye’s honeyed vocals flow beautifully around the big crunch of the drums and bass on this track, produced by D’Mile. “I can feel your water comin” over me, diving underwater till I’m lost at sea.”
  • Ice Spice, “Gimme a Light” – Ice Spice’s diamond-hard percussive flow gets a fantastic showcase on this Sean Paul-sampling sparse track produced by RIOTUSA. “She gettin’ loud but nobody moved; watch the TV, I’m makin’ the news.”
  • PinkPantheress, “Turn It Up” – This single from English singer-songwriter PinkPantheress brought her work into sharp relief for me and it was one of my favorite discoveries of the year (another case where I’m late to the party). This song about a tenuous relationship (if not obsession) uses moody production that has flavors of 2-step garage around its edges to evoke that feeling when the mood in a club shifts better than almost any song I can remember. “Tell me why you’re always here at night? Turn it up! It seems to me it’s the only time I see you. And when I thought I found my purpose in life, you’re not there.”
  • Shannon and the Clams, “The Moon is in the Wrong Place” – Shannon and the Clams’ gorgeous and heartbreaking new record – this is the title track – was born out of struggling with the untimely death of Shannon Shaw’s fiance, Joe Haener; I wouldn’t wish that on anyone. This record is a balm and a reminder that we can even dance about the terrible times; sometimes we need to. “Colors changed when you left this world – now everything’s a whiter shade of mauve. I’m seeing bright spots, shiny objects that you use for those you love: I spy seafoam, I spy olive, I spy golden candlelight. I spy something that you told me in the last week of our lives.”
  • Dave Alvin and Jimmie Dale Gilmore, “We’re Still Here” – This duet statement of purpose is a highlight of Dave Alvin and Jimmie Dale Gilmore’s second collaborative record Trying To Be Free, with a killing Alvin guitar solo and gorgeous intertwined B-3 and piano, connecting the two kinds of honky tonks that were fertile soil for the evolution of American music. “Well, a music business man with a music business smile said the songs that I write were old and out of style. But I’ve been boppin’ these blues for for over forty years. Hell, I don’t know where he is but we’re still here.”
  • Sabrina Carpenter, “Please Please Please” – Obviously one of the biggest breakout successes this year and I loved Short n’ Sweet as much as everyone, with this grinning put-your-man-in-his-place song and its vibe pop/roller disco groove. The rippling synth lines and those twangy smears on the vocals got their hooks in me immediately. “Heartbreak is one thing, my ego’s another; I beg you don’t embarrass me, motherfucker.”
  • Kaitlin Butts, “Other Girls (Ain’t Havin’ Any Fun)” – Kaitlin Butts’ Roadrunner! is my favorite contemporary reimagining of Western Swing in many years and this kiss off torch ballad is a highlight in a record full of highlights, featuring pedal steel like smoke rising off her in a film noir spotlight. “They say, ‘Other girls don’t act like this,’ that it’s poison on the tongue. They say, ‘Other girls don’t act like this,’ oh, but other girls ain’t having any fun.”
  • Emily Nenni, “I Don’t Have to Like You” – This standout from Emily Nenni’s great Drive & Cry has a swaggering, easy going beat dripping with organ shoving her voice into the foreground. “Well, it took time but I learned how not to feed the flame of folks like you. I can’t linger or I’ll burn a hole, that’s just what my eyes do.”
  • Luci Kaye Booth, “Damn Good In a Dive Bar” – This favorite track for me from Booth’s great The Loneliest Girl in the World has a simple arrangement that uses space around those guitar stabs and dusky drums very effectively but for me, this one is all about the tumble of words with the razor-cut alliteration and internal rhymes belied by the perfectly nonchalant vocal delivery. “All eyes on the high-rise Levi’s in the low light; boys say, ‘Hey there, ain’t you a sight.’ You can write my name in Sharpie on the wall, but you can’t take me home when they’re calling last call. Two-dollar buzz, breaking neon hearts: I look pretty damn good in a dive bar.”
  • Maren Morris, “Push Me Over” – I’ve long been a subscriber to the theory (I first heard from the Supersuckers’ Eddie Spaghetti) that every band’s disco record is my favorite record of this, and now I’ve added Maren Morris to that list. This overheated seduction was one of my favorite jams of the summer and works just as well in the cold of December. “Even if it’s just tonight, you still got me to the other side, but did you push me over, or did I? Either way, I gotta say, no hesitations.”
  • Carsie Blanton, “My Good Friends” – This highlight from Carsie Blanton’s terrific After The Revolution uses a campfire-folk arrangement to get this simple, profound message about how much we need other people in times of celebration and need. “When the darkness descends, I call up my good friends. They come down to the riverbed and crack me up until the light gets in.”
  • Amy Rigby, “Bad in a Good Way” – One of my favorite singer-songwriters, Amy Rigby, returned with her best record in years – maybe since MiddlescenceHang In There With Me. One of my favorite modes of Rigby is her character writing, and this affectionate eyebrow-raised capture of a life through his funeral was an instant favorite of mine; a stunning example of her laid-back, beckoning delivery and an interesting arrangement, shot through with drones. “He was the same as desert weather, he held it all together. Dry and gritty with a chill, but he wished nobody ill. He was pure Play It As It Lays, he was as sure as ‘Glory Days,’ the ones they thought would never end. Beneath it all, he was a friend who found a way not to be sad at all the love he could’ve had. He wasn’t good the way they say; he was bad.”
  • Queen Naija, “Good Girls Finish Last” – One of my favorite discoveries this year and one of my favorite R&B singles – the circling, “No you don’t know what you want,” gets stuck in my head for days every time I play it.
  • Shemeika Copeland, “Only Miss You All The Time”Blame It On Eve was a high-watermark for one of the most storied blues-folk singers of my lifetime, pairing Shemeika Copeland’s voice in astonishing form paired with Will Kimbrough’s production and stabbing guitar on this song (which Kimbrough also co-wrote), a sparse punch in the chest and a flickering flame in the darkness on a record that struck me over and over. “I miss you, lover, I miss you, friend. If I never see you again: it wasn’t you, it wasn’t me; just a love not meant to be.”
  • MJ Lenderman, “She’s Leaving You” – I resisted the Lenderman record Manning Fireworks at first – praise was a little too effusive, a little too universal, but as soon as I finally heard it I was in love. This song in particular, with its keening chorus, “It falls apart; we’ve all got work to do” and that chiming, ragged guitar gave me the best early-Wilco-conjuring feelings I’ve gotten from any record in many years.
  • George Strait, “Rent” – This highlight off George Strait’s remarkably consistent 31st album Cowboys and Dreamers opens with a directly addressed shoutout to its two (now gone from us) songwriters, Texas master of empathy and hooks Guy Clark and Keith Gattis (whose “El Cerrito Place” is one of my favorite ballads of the last 20 years and made my “Parting Gifts” playlist last year), and makes excellent use of Strait’s elder statesman voice and a subtle, devastating arrangement. “He said, ‘The war took my brother. The good Lord took my mother. And the years, well, I don’t know where they all went. Until that roll is called up yonder, all I can do is wonder if I even did enough to make a dent. But I made a few good friends, and I always paid my rent.”
  • Linda Thompson featuring Kami Thompson, “The Solitary Traveller” – This opening track from Linda Thompson’s return Proxy Music, named because these originals are performed by other artists, set the tone for an astonishing return, with a magical vocal from Thompson’s daughter Kami. “Lonely life, where is thy sting? Lonely life? There’s no such thing.”
  • Nick Lowe and Los Straitjackets, “Crying Inside” – At long last, the collaboration of one of the great power-pop (and other modes) songwriters and surf champions gave us a full-length and it exceeded even my high expectations. This song in particular is as good as anything Lowe has ever written and recorded. “I’m standing in a jolly crowd – joking, laughing a little too loud. Looking like the model of a man who’s got it made. But my repartee is just to disguise all the hurt I’m trying to hide.”
  • The Harlem Gospel Travelers, “We Don’t Love Enough” – For their follow up Rhapsody, back with producer and mentor Eli “Paperboy” Reed is a luminous cover of The Triumphs’ “We Don’t Love Enough” that I first heard on the seminal Numero comp Good God! They don’t just do it justice, they take it into space. The way they sing “It’s a shame…” was as heavy as whole lyrics on other songs and a much needed message in this fucked-up year.
  • Etran de L’air, “Igrawahi” – I’ve liked all the bands I’ve heard out of the Tuareg blues-rock scene exporting to the Europe and the States over the last ten years, but Etran de L’air – who I was lucky enough to see twice this year, at festivals that sometimes feel on opposite ends of the spectrum, Big Ears and Gonerfest – bring a different flavor with a rhythm section that recalls the loose euphoria of garage rock.
  • Charli XCX, “Club classics” – I didn’t love Charli XCX’s Brat quite as much as her last record but that was an extremely high bar for me and it was full of sticky candy and swirling summer jams. This grappling with nostalgia/tipping of the hat, set to a powerful groove was a favorite. “Play the track fast, not slow; pull it back twice, let go.”
  • Love Fiend, “Just For Eddie” – Another undeniable groove and grappling with nostalgia and the sometimes-disconnection baked into how we live our lives, and a beautiful eulogy (I think) from an angle more inspired by vintage ’70s pub rock and a cornerstone of one of my favorite rock records of the year. “Save a nickel, save a dime, so you can play a song one at a time: ‘Trouble in Mind’ or ‘Heartbreak Hotel,’ the 45’s got you under its spell.”
  • Freak Genes, “Clear in the Night” – This cracked garage/industrial blend from Cincinnati’s Feel It records feels tailor-made for fans of Gorgio Murderer and Optic Sink, and is their most beguiling worldbuilding on record yet. “Excess on demand.”
  • X, “Big Black X” – If Smoke & Fiction really is their last statement, pioneering West Coast post-punk band X – still with the original members John Doe, Exene Cervenka, Billy Zoom, and DJ Bonebrake – it’s a hell of a way to go out on. Ending this little section of the playlist with another deep groove and a gimlet eyed looking back, cut with diamonds and sung like a heart being sprayed by a flamethrower with the two voices coming together on maybe my favorite chorus all year. “Stay awake and don’t get taken. We knew the gutter, also the future.”
  • Gouge Away, “Maybe Blue” – Transitioning out of that handful of songs with a favorite young rock band that grew out of X and their scene, and the hardcore boiling around them, and crafted a completely fresh, head-knocking mix of elements I thought I’d grown tired of before hearing Deep Sage. “Can we go back to when the ceiling was breathing? Can we go back to when the wood grain was dripping?”
  • Ancient Peach, “Lovers Run” – A favorite new local band featuring Ginny Riot – a musician I’d follow into any new project – on guitar and vocals (shared with bassist Lauren Lever), and their EP was the best heavy, swinging shoegaze I’ve heard in a long while. “No offense, but they never told; and the silence grows.”
  • Angélica Garcia, “Juanita”– Garcia’s third album, Gemelo, knocked me sideways and the insistent beat and restrained vocal on the verses that both explode into a sculpture of fireworks on the chorus was a prime example of why.
  • Bette Smith, “Happiness” – Brooklyn-via-Memphis soul-rock singer Bette Smith made her best record yet, Goodthing, expanding on the multitude of pleasures from The Good, The Bad, and the Bette but giving it a brighter, more nuanced three-dimensionality. “Take a shot of freedom. Now how ya feeling?”
  • Amanda Anne Platt and the Honeycutters, “Mirage” – I was primed for The Ones That Stay after seeing a stunning Amanda Anne Platt and the Honeycutters show at Natalie’s this year and this song that struck me live stabbed daggers in my heart on the record. That shattering piano line the steel guitar orbits around, giving her band space to breathe, grabs me by the collar every time. “I take a toothpick and I walk outside – the sky is lavender and rose gold. Another sweet and salty summer night; an empty road that smells like charcoal. I strain to hear the angels sing, but they don’t owe me anything.
  • Memphis Royal Brothers, featuring Wendy Moten and Jim Lauderdale, “Brand New Heart”—This Memphis supergroup/Royal Studios house band features a backbone of legends like Lester Snell, Charles Hodges, and Michael Toles. On this debut record, they pair that tasteful firepower with killer new songs. This duet between legendary country songwriter Jim Lauderdale and Wendy Moten is a love duet for the ages. “Love’s an invitation to start your life again; a perfect celebration that doesn’t have to end.”
  • Ella Langley, “I Blame the Bar” – Like I suspect a lot of listeners, I found Ella Langley through that ubiquitous TikTok song, but the more I dug into her record hungover it kept revealing things, and this song has the best bad-idea-seduction chorus in years, up there with classics like Dolly Parton’s “Why’d You Come In Here Looking Like That” and Ani Difranco’s “Shy.” “No, I don’t blame you that it didn’t work out. Even if I used to, baby, I don’t now. It was the two-for-ones, being young and dumb, that everyone’s gotta go through.”
  • Dehd, “Hard to Love” – Another example that friends are the most reliable indicator of new bands as two different pals suggested Dehd’s record Poetry and I fell quickly in love, and this dust-spattered reckless backroads drive is a prime example of what keeps me coming back to it. “Gotta love the good man, but that ain’t what I want. Give me someone rough and tumble, someone hard to love.”
  • Raul Malo, “I Got Stripes” – One of the great American voices paired with one of the quintessential American songs, Johnny Cash’s Leadbelly adaptation, exceeded even those high expectations and gave us probably the definitive version; damn sure the only one that made me forget the original for as long as it’s running. “Them chains, them chains, they’re about to drag me down.”
  • Thee Sacred Souls, “Price I’ll Pay” – Cali sweet soul torchbearers Thee Sacred Souls knocked it out of the park with the sun-dappled harmonies and silky rhythms of Got a Story To Tell. In a record of gems, this one stuck in my throat every time I played it. “With every new season, I want to explore you.”
  • Muni Long, “Type Questions” – This finger snap-driven torch ballad was an immediate standout for me from Muni Long’s consistently great Revenge and a song I’ve revisited often over 2024. “I’m good at making something out of nothing – how come you never asked me if I have a husband?”
  • Moor Mother and Sistazz of the Nitty Gritty, “SOUTH SEA” – Moor Mother continued her streak of one of the great no-filler exploratory catalogs in music today with The Great Bailout. This expansive 9-minute track finds Moor Mother in her spoken word mode with fascinating backgrounds shifting between wordless gospel croons, vocalese, and a questing, mournful clarinet rising out of a horn section. Gorgeous and haunting. “Sometimes the killing is silent / So silent you can almost hear the chaos of people gathering / spells and curses in their head”
  • The Bellrays, “All The Rage” – After a six-year gap, Lisa Kekaula’s soul-injected rock band returns with a record of wall-to-wall firey power. This one captures the riffs, surging vocals, and swinging stomp of a rhythm section that’s always made The Bellrays so intoxicating. “Is it the morning after or the night before? This room is getting darker than it’s ever been before.”
  • Jake Blount and Mali Obomsawin, “What’s You Gonna Do When The Word’s On Fire”Symbiont, a masterpiece in folky, collaged, deconstructionist indigenous futurism brings together Jake Blount and Mali Obomsawin and finds all of their interests and earlier work coalescing in a way that dazzles me every time. “You are a fragment of a whole carrying with you a small, small role that multiplies with you. Remember you instructions: at the end you too will return to soil.”
  • Seun Kuti and Egypt 80, “Well Well Well” – Another extension and continuation of vintage Afrobeat that doesn’t shut out the present in any sense. A dance floor monster that orbits around Kuti’s sweet tenor and sticky horn lines I can’t help singing along to. “Many are falling and they don’t know because the world dey upside down.”
  • Common and Pete Rock featuring Bilal, “So Many People” – In a similar warm, throwback mode the match-made-in-heaven pairing of Common and Pete Rock returns to the hip-hop-as-woman metaphor of so much of Common’s work with a beat full of interesting flourishes moving with a light touch, and remarkable feature vocals from Bilal. “She showed up for me in the darkest times; conversations with her re-spark my mind.”
  • Mourning [A] BLKstar, “Just Can’t Be” – Cleveland’s avant-funk collective put out another crushing record with the lush and searching Ancient//Future, the interplay of the horns and vocals on this over the creeping flow of the beat sends this one over the top for me. “I am to blame, but you are the root.”
  • Jenny Scheinman, “Ornette Goes Home” – Maybe this is a more likely candidate for the Spaces list, but violinist/composer Jenny Scheinman’s new one All Species Parade roared out of the gate with this eulogy/tribute that’s rich with the same kind of melodic earworms Ornette was known for and that beat and searching quality just sort of fused itself in my head alongside the Mourning [A]BLKstar – Scheinman’s violin glides over and through Bill Frisell’s guitar and Carmen Staaf’s piano, with Frisell’s frequent rhythm section of Tony Scherr and Kenny Wollensen slyly winking at the Haden/Higgins hookup without slavishly recreating it.
  • Rema and Shallpopi, “BENIN BOYS” – I’m not as well-versed as I should be on the current Nigerian pop/afrobeats scene but I loved the silky, beckoning quality of this gold-plated pop collaboration as soon as I heard it. Those synth horn stabs both reminded me of the last couple of tracks and I thought set up the shift into the next few pieces. “If you play with the boys, you go collect.”
  • Ibibio Sound Machine, “Let My Yes Be Yes” – One of my favorite contemporary funk bands, London’s Ibibio Sound Machine, continued their unique fusion of elements with a sensibility that balances the groove and the song with uncommon delicateness for as powerfully thumping as these tunes are, with their remarkable Pull the Rope. “A better way for me to find me, just need to get you, get you behind me.
  • Nubiyan Twist featuring Nile Rodgers and The Reflex, “Lights Out (The Reflex Revision)” – The same feeling as the above with a late ’70s flavor – even featuring one of the architects of that sound – from the same UK scene as Ibibio Sound Machine and remixed by long running DJ The Reflex, this is like eating too much candy or having three too many drinks. “Down with the silence. Free your mind, let’s shake with the vibrance.”
  • Latto, “Big Mama” – Columbus native who came into her own in the Atlanta scene, Latto’s Sugar Honey Iced Tea is her best record yet and this seductive braggadocious track produced by COUPE, OZ, and Kid Masterpiece is an addictive string of earworms and hurts-so-good one liners. “Drinking out the bottle til this shit is done. On some Andre 3K shit, man, where the fuck my panties at?”
  • Luno Moon and Garlic Jr., “DRUNK ON A WEDNESDAY” – There’s a fascinating scene of exploratory, avant-leaning R&B in Columbus right now and Hakim Callwood – in his Garlic Jr. guise – and Luno Moon are at the center of it. This twisty song – those stuttered synths under the insistent drums kill me – sums up that sense of stasis between unhinged exuberance and regret and is as addictive as the behavior in the title. “Here time isn’t linear, how much of it do we have? My nose and my arms are wide open – come closer to me, let’s relapse on our love.”
  • Tinashe, “Getting No Sleep” – I love even the uneven Tinashe records, and I think Quantum Baby is one of her best – this clattering beat with the subdued synths sets up a smoky vocal that plays to all her strengths and a hook I hum for days every time I play it. “We ain’t getting no sleep, no, no, we’re just living instead. We can sleep when we’re dead.”
  • Shovels and Rope, “Piranhanana” – Shovels and Rope put out their rawest, meanest, most rocking record with Something is Working Above My Head and it was a breakthrough for a band I already loved. This swinging steamroller of an early single conjures vintage T Rex and AC/DC with the close harmonies melting into gang vocals. “Forlorn, used to lose it – skips the beat and gets straight to the bruisin’.”
  • MC Lyte, “All Day All Night” – With a laid-back boom-bap infused organ trio- recalling backing track produced by Easy Mo Bee, a revitalized MC Lyte made something that always makes me grin like an idiot, a standout on a brilliant restatement record 1 on 1. “Older now, with him here in front of me, it was clear he had no idea what he’d done for me: made me feel love, gave me hope like ‘Yes,’ in a world full of nopes, it was me that he caressed.”
  • Masha Marjieh, “Come Inside” – I’d been waiting for a proper Masha Marjieh – a crucial component of the classic run of one of my five favorite Detroit rock bands of my lifetime (I said what I said) The Deadstring Brothers – solo record and the psych-drenched Past Present Future more than delivered. This deliberately paced distillation of desire is a highlight for me on a record without any weak links, with one of my favorite bass lines and a organ part I want to sink into. “Whisper to me softly, please, how you’ll take me when you need.”
  • Samora Pinderhughes, “Drown” – I’ve liked Samora Pinderhughes but his performance at LPR during Winter Jazz Fest this year meant I was hungry for this new record and I was more than rewarded by Venus Smiles Not in the House of Tears, a damn masterpiece that’s still revealing truths to me. And this blown-glass piano ballad fucking levels me. “No sound, no sound around. I’m not too proud of what I’ve found. It won’t change until I face it, take a deep breath, and drown. Don’t take your eyes off the sea.”
  • Zach Bryan, “Bass Boat” – Speaking of songs that leveled me this year – I liked most of The Great American Bar Scene the way I like most of Bryan’s work; I’m a sucker for Springsteen-ish words sprayed like a firehouse. But this is one of the maybe 10 songs of his that hit me like a sledgehammer, piano-driven, and that backing vocal like a shadow or a conscience wrapped around the words. Just perfect. “I ain’t never been one for cheap excuses, and apologies have always been a little late or useless, but if you give me four minutes and a little bit of time, I’ll make them old days an old friend of mine.”
  • Maia Jarrett featuring The InBetweens, “Hold Me” – This striking single from Maia Jarrett, carrying on the lineage of her father bass player Noah Jarrett and featuring Jarrett’s collaborative trio The InBetweens with Conor Elmes on drums and percussion and Mike Gamble on guitar and electronics on sympathetic backing, is one of the most assured debuts I’ve heard in a very long time. Jarrett’s words and piano create an entire universe here, a forest of dancing razor blades and smoke that is specific in its intent but leaves enough mystery to keep me intrigued. “Being the girl that I used to hate: stable enough to open my eyes to fate.”
  • Cassandra Jenkins, “Clams Casino” – I loved Jenkins’ last record and My Light, My Destroyer, might be even better. It’s a slower burn but keeps sharing things with me, and this song – with its sidewalk-dancing rumble and guitar bursts – got me immediately. “I might never land on solid grounds. Part of me will always be in the clouds in an old suit in my hotel room, but I don’t wanna laugh alone anymore.”
  • Melissa Carper, “Borned in Ya” – Carper crosses western wing and honky tonk with a modern sensibility as well as anyone working and this ferocious, infectiously fun drawing of sides, with stinging electric guitar and a rich baritone sax telling the story as much as her intriguing voice, should be a standard if there’s any justice in the world. “Mama she sang to us, she borned it in us, and Daddy played those old records, and I remember sometimes he’d cry to hear those soulful sounds. Now I know what Daddy found.”
  • Dwight Yoakam, “I’ll Pay The Price” – The modern master at mixing the ancient and the immediate, Dwight Yoakam returned with his best record in almost 20 years – Brighter Days – and this song is pure, vintage Dwight in the best possible way. “Take any deal thrown by your hand and pay the price to hold it again.”
  • Maya de Vitry, “Compass” – Maya de Vitry’s song “How Bad I Want to Live” from 2022’s Violet Light was an immediate anthem and guiding light for me, on a record whose beauty I’m still digging into. Her new one The Only Moment was another stunner with a tight band that made me sorry I couldn’t make her tour stop at Natalie’s work with scheduling. This is my favorite song from it, insistent, burrowing right into my chest. “Sorry to hear that I let you down. Sorrier to know you were thinking I was here just holding up high some idea you had about me. I get it, I get mad too.”
  • Katie Mae and the Lubrication, “Hard Enough” – One of the most exciting new Americana bands to come down the pike in a minute, from the fertile Phoenix scene, Katie Mae and the Lubrication’s The Sighs & Strength hit every pleasure center I have focused around that genre with sharply defined songs and crisp playing. This was an instant favorite of mine from that first line. “Well, I picked up all my habits from my stupid-ass friends; I always feel lucky just to see them again. Life’s too short too let good loved ones go, too long without you telling them so. And everything else is hard enough.”
  • Watershed, “Sensational Things” – Columbus powerpop lifers Watershed returned in 2024 with one of their best records yet, Blow It Up Before It Breaks, up there with Star Vehicle and The More It Hurts, The More It Works. Re-teaming with Tim Patalan, it’s a collection of finely polished, vibrant gems, speckled with enough of the dust of living life to keep them interesting. This song about clinging to and finding that beauty in life is easily in my top ten for a band I dismissed early and really came to in the last 15 years. “I was killing time at the 8 Ball; ran into the drummer from my old band. As luck would have it, he was still going at it. Over drinks, we hatched a plan. Wondering who would show up as the band’s tuning up, I spotted you by the stage, all alone. As I stepped to the mic, you swayed and closed your eyes. I knew I was finally home.”
  • PyPy, “Poodle Wig” – The single set I was sorriest to miss at this year’s admirably-rain-fighting Gonerfest was Montreal’s PyPy, and their record Sacred Times ground glass in that wound. This hooky, buoyand song is a prime example of the joys splashed all over the record.
  • Davóne Tines and the Truth, “This Little Light” – At the forefront of modern and avant-garde opera, Tines took my breath away at Big Ears, and his tribute to the great Paul Robeson, ROBESOИ, more than delivered on what made me weep in the Tennesee Theatre at one in the afternoon. Robeson was one of my Grandmother’s – the font of all my taste, pretty much – favorites and I hate to speak for the dead but I think she would have loved this ecstatic, wrenching cry of a version of this at least as much as I do. Maybe more. “Let it shine.”
  • Gillian Welch and David Rawlings, “Hashtag” – The partnership who’ve given the world the catalog with the most classics in all of roots music for the last 30 years returned with the breathtaking Woodland Studios. Every song on it kills me, but this tribute to Guy Clark both a mentor for them and an inspiration for the kind of deep empathy and understanding, gives me chills every time. “You laughed and said the news would be bad if I ever saw your name with a hashtag. Singers like you and I are only news when we die. So here I’m sitting ’round another night, looking at your boots, Jesus Christ.”
  • Aaron Lee Tasjan, “Shining Down” – A highlight from the remarkable Jesse Malin tribute/fundraiser Silver Patron Saints, Columbus expat based in Nashville Aaron Lee Tasjan – who also put out a great record of his own this year, Stellar Evolution – who kicked around Malin’s New York milieu for some formative years, turned this wistful miniature from Sunset Kids into a hushed cri de coeur. The atmospherics – the massed vocals, the glistening finger-picked guitar – fit the gorgeous vocal perfectly. “I found another path through the broken glass. Everything was trash, but it all worked out. Keep on shining down on my life.”
  • Steve Dawson, “Time To Let Some Light In” – Chicago singer-songwriter Steve Dawson who I’ve been a fan of since Dolly Varden put out one of the best records in a career that doesn’t have any bad ones, Ghosts, this year, digging deeper into the intersection between laurel canyon singer-songwriter and Hi Records buttery soul, with – as usual – some of the greatest players working in one of the best music scenes in America, including the supple rhythm section of John Abbey and Gerald Dowd alongside the simmering organ of Alton Smith. “Freedom is another word for scared to death. I’m old and I’m tired and I’m running out of breath. It’s time to let some light in; I’ve done enough crying.”
  • Joy Oladokun, “QUESTIONS, CHAOS, & FAITH” – Joy Oladokun’s Observations From A Crowded Room was the only other record that immediately made me think “Fuck, record of the year,” alongside the Hurray for the Riff Raff I mentioned at the beginning of this list, and it’s still up there. I still play it almost daily – the opening up of Oladokun’s soundworld with electronic rhythms, choral backing, new textures on her astonishing voice, stepped up the work of an artist I already loved. Thanks for reading whatever part of this you did – I leave you with this hope-at-a-slant slice of beauty. “Nothing is certain, everything changes. We’re spirit and bone, marching to the grave. There are no answers, there are only questions, chaos and faith.”

Categories
Uncategorized

Best of 2024 – Recorded Music

As usual, more detailed thoughts on these will come – along with other songs that stuck in my chest – on the playlist posts later in the month. And while I no longer rank – though there’s a top 10 and an additional 10 – the record I came back to the most often, I turned over in my head repeatedly, and I kept finding new things to delight in was this year’s Hurray for the Riff Raff. Until Joy Oladokun’s new one came out, there wasn’t even a question about my “Record of the Year”. And while I’ve only lived with the Oladokun for a minute, it gives me that same blood-pumping feeling, and I can’t wait to see her come through the Newport in June.

  • Hurray for the Riff Raff, The Past Is Still Alive
  • Joy Oladokun, Observations from a Crowded Room
  • Various Artists, Silver Patron Saints: The Songs of Jesse Malin
  • Mary Halvorson, Cloudward
  • Meshell Ndegeocello, No More Water: The Gospel of James Baldwin
  • DEHD, Poetry
  • Wadada Leo Smith and Amina Claudine Myers, Central Park’s Mosaic of Reservoir, Lake, Paths, and Gardens
  • Lucky Daye, Algorithm
  • Tim Easton, Find Your Way
  • Arooj Aftab, Night Reign
  • Kris Davis Trio, Run the Gauntlet
  • Amy Rigby, Hang in There With Me
  • David Murray Quartet, Francesca
  • Kaitlin Butts, Roadrunner!
  • Sarah Davachi, The Head as Form’d in the Crier’s Choir
  • Chuck Prophet featuring ¿Qiensave?, Wake The Dead
  • Kyshona, Legacy
  • Davóne Tines and The Truth, ROBESOИ
  • Dalia Stasevska, Dalia’s Mixtape
  • Nubya Garcia, Odyssey
Categories
Best Of live music

2021 Best Of – Live Music

Reigning Sound, Gonerfest

Seeing music in (usually small) rooms with like-minded people has – for my adult life and a few years before – been the art form I’ve thrown myself into with the most gusto, where I’ve met the largest groups of my dearest friends, and the most constant source of picking me up and putting me back together when I’ve been down. 

So, the return to that energy, that joy, that magic – even in modified forms, with fewer artists back on the road – was a balm and a beachhead against so much despair this year. It’s unsurprising of the 75ish nights I found myself in a room soaking up some sounds, Dick’s Den saw me the most often at 13 times as of last night.  

Dick’s is also where I found myself, against a wall, talking to old friend and drummer Pauly Abbott, about that surge of energy from people I was used to seeing at shows then didn’t see at all when things switched to live streaming. I am eternally grateful for the close friends I’d see on one of our lawns or a coffeeshop patio, but my extroverted nature craved those next concentric circles of people. Friends I have real love for and who add vital color to my life even if our friendships are more situational in nature. Thank you all, whether you read this or not. 

Jerry Wolf, The Top Steakhouse

That’s also not to overlook the streams that kept giving me a little taste of music happening, music unwilling to be stopped. It was a little bittersweet when the regular streaming series of John Paul Keith and Jesse Malin came to an end, I’m glad ongoing series from Goner Records in Memphis and SFJAZZ in San Francisco persist, and I hope we’ll find a way to keep making these available for people who can’t get to a show as easily. 

I don’t know what happens next, but I’m profoundly, jubilantly grateful for everything listed below, and far more shows than this best-of-the-best 20. Everything is in chronological order. In Columbus unless otherwise specified. All photographs taken (with varying degrees of ineptitude) by me. 

The Veldt, Pour House, Raleigh
  • Jerry Wolf, The Top Steakhouse, 04/24/2021 (and other nights) – The first indoor dining Anne and I treated ourselves to was classic steakhouse and cocktail bar The Top. One of the signature pleasures of this gently-updated since the ‘50s room is the curved piano bar in the corner, where we always try to either start or end up with one of their perfect martinis or manhattans; three of those nights we were lucky enough to have Columbus jazz and cabaret legend Jerry Wolf rain down pure, icepick-in-the-heart beauty. An encyclopedic array of songs – I’d ask for “Try to Remember” for Anne or her mom and he’d expand it into a bouquet of songs from The Fantasticks; I’d mention Cole Porter and for the next ten minutes, he’d build intricate harmonic bridges from “Just One of Those Things” through “Don’t Fence Me In” onward to “Night and Day.” And he’d take requests from folks with less interest in standards than I have – one night we heard a surprisingly spry, sparkling “Hotel California” waft over the tables – but just getting to appreciate one of the masters of this art, of this love, of the middle 20th century American song, is something I treasured every minute of and anyone in Columbus should avail themselves of at least once. 
  • Reigning Sound, Harbor Town Amphitheater, 06/05/2021, and Railgarten (Gonerfest), both Memphis, 09/24/2021 – We already had plans for a beach house recharge trip with dear friends the following week of June but the confluence of surprisingly cheap flights and the opportunity to make the last band we saw out of town – in Cleveland the same weekend the first cases of COVID were identified in Ohio – the first band we saw out of town, in their hometown of Memphis, for just one additional vacation day was too tempting to pass up. Still cautiously placed in an outdoor amphitheater we’d never visited on our trips to town, Anne and I were treated to a dazzling set from an expanded Reigning Sound – the classic four-piece lineup of Greg Cartwright on guitar and vocals, Jeremy Scott on bass and harmonies, Greg Roberson on drums and percussion, Alex Greene on organ and guitar, augmented by Graham Winchester on drums and percussion, John Whittemore on various guitars and pedal steel, cellist Elen Wroten, violinist Krista Wroten, and Cartwright’s Parting Gifts partner Coco Hames on additional vocals – hitting most of their joyous, sun-drenched 2021 release A Little More Time With Reigning Sound – and more classics than I had the right to expect, in interesting arrangements. When we saw them again three months later – with that same lineup, but with Marcella Simien in place of Hames – there was the added magic of Gonerfest sprinkled over everything, gorgeous weather, and a dancing crowd, but I still remember the sigh of relief on that rainy June afternoon. 
  • The Veldt, Pour House, Raleigh, 06/12/2021 – We bookended that trip with an overnight in Raleigh. The best part of that stop was seeing old friend and mentor Rich Dansky on his home turf for the first time in years, but I also found time to be stunned by a set from reunited shoegaze-soul band The Veldt at the terrific venue/record store combo Pour House. A sticky afternoon and songs I didn’t know that hit everything I want in a band. Pure, rejuvenating magic. 
Sylvia Cuenca Quintet, Smalls, NYC
  • Brett Burleson Quartet, Dick’s Den, 07/02/2021 – Brett’s not only a friend but a pillar of the jazz scene here in town I love so much. This was one of the first trips back to Dick’s, along with a Rhinestone Quartet show a couple weeks earlier Brett also played in, where everything felt right. A whirlwind of love: hugging old friends, watching no-bullshit jazz played so directly and passionately it moved crowds to press against the stage and throw each other around the dance floor. Around midnight, the throbbing rhythm section of Will Strickler on bass and Antoine Fatout on drums locked into Monk’s “Rhythm-a-ning” and Brett’s guitar and Eddie Bayard’s tenor took us into the eye of a delirious hurricane. Every one of the other six or seven times I’ve seen these gentlemen on a stage has given me a few of those moments, and this reminder sank right into my bones. 
  • Sylvia Cuenca Quintet, Smalls, NYC, 07/16/2021 – Much as I missed that feeling of jazz in a room with people who appreciate the magic of those moments being captured, the beauty of how fleeting it is, I have a special affection for it in New York City, the cradle of most of the jazz I’ve grown up loving. So, it’s no surprise not only would Anne and I make New York one of our first stops after being vaccinated, but jazz would be a key component of that return. This trip to Smalls, always a firecracker of a time, featured a riveting hard bop set from drummer Sylvia Cuenca leading a quintet of rhythm section partners Dave Kikoski on piano and Essiet Essiet on bass behind a smoldering frontline of Craig Handy and Freddie Hendrix. 
  • Kim Richey, Natalie’s Grandview, 07/30/2021 – Natalie’s usually features heavily in this list and 2021 is no exception – with one of the roughest hands dealt a venue (not that it’s ever a competition), Natalie and Charlie Jackson had just opened their larger Grandview location and they were working out the kinks when everything shut down. Kim Richey was one of the many acts I hadn’t seen since Little Brothers closed, and this set commemorating the belated 20th anniversary of the record that turned me onto her and the first tour of hers I saw, Glimmer, summed up everything I keep going to singer-songwriter shows for. Accompanied by a lead guitarist – I wrote the name as “Sam” but didn’t catch the last name – she hit most of that record, along with stories about some of her co-writers like frequent Natalie’s visitor Chuck Prophet and some other stone-cold favorites of mine. Watching her lean into “Chase Wild Horses,” curling those lines like a beckoning, “I’m all done running from the way I was before. Things I’ve done that I ain’t proud of, I can’t even stand the sound of; I still hear them knocking at my door,” pinballed through my body as I walked down King Avenue into the night. 
Tony Monaco Quartet, Woodlands Tavern
  • Huntertones, Natalie’s Grandview, 08/07/2021 – Columbus’s current most prominent local-kids-made-good story, jazz-jam band the Huntertones have been impressing me since they were college students here under the name the Dan White Sextet, and it’s a pleasure to not only see them setting New York and the wider jam scene on fire but also watch their music get more expansive and more in tune with who they are and who they want to be. This homecoming show – I caught the afternoon of their three gigs – was a delightful callback and a reminder of the joy of everyone being together, underlined by an impassioned speech from reeds player White between songs about the energy exchange between band and audience. The touching love everyone on stage had for everyone else lit that room up like a paper lantern, burning through my hangover and making my heart pump a little harder to tunes like “Burns” with its sun-dappled pop-funk textures mingling with second line crunch; a classic quiet storm number turning into a storm of robot bees with angular improvisation; and a gnarled, righteously boozy Chris Ott trombone solo with White and Jon Lampley throwing harmonies off it that sounded like a war cry for the party just around the corner. 
  • The Three Speeds, Vanderelli Room/Paisha, Secret Studio; 08/14/2021 – Coming out of the last lockdown, a little shell-shocked, I was heartened to see venues springing up and working together. One of my favorite examples of that synchronicity was Franklinton art gallery pillar, Vanderelli Room, creating an outdoor stage for a fun, raucous concert series, and then coordinating it with neighbors, and more recent Franklinton residents, Secret Studio, so the two complimented each other instead of competing. That led to one of my favorite days of the summer. First, Columbus rock lifers The Three Speeds, fronted by guitarist/singer Matt Wyatt, with his brother Chris on second guitar and harmonies, and one of my favorite rock rhythm sections (as people and as players) Gene Brodeur and Eddie Blau, churned through a set of raw, catchy-nasty classic punk rock. Over at Secret Studio, Paisha Thomas, performing and recording as Paisha, had one of those sets where everything just clicked for me. She’s long been one of my favorite voices in Columbus, but I didn’t vibe with the songs as much as the voice and the charisma, this time everything fired at the same level. A tight sympathetic band of local legends – Stan Smith on guitar, Steve Perakis on bass, Danny Aguiar on drums – helped, but it was entirely Paisha’s show. When I see a singer do one of my all-time, 20th century favorite songs, Percy Mayfield’s “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” so well it at once becomes the benchmark I set that song against, and I’m still raving about their own songs later that night, it’s a special, special show. 
  • Tony Monaco Quartet, Woodlands Tavern, 08/14/2021 and other dates – Tony Monaco’s one of the great ambassadors of the grooving Columbus B-3 tradition (with Bobby Floyd being the other). Through playing with nationally-renowned greats like Joey DeFrancesco, regular touring of Japan, and building bridges to younger bands and audiences through years of residencies at non-jazz venues. He was one of the first acts I saw after getting vaccinated, in a trio with drummer Tony McClung and saxophone maestro Eddie Bayard, and I saw him as recently as this past weekend, always delivering, reading the crowd and tweaking his approach to the audience without pandering and changing the core of who he is. The packed Saturday night dancefloor in one of our best sounding clubs, as pal John Turck (also a keyboardist and bandleader) said, “I knew he’d be funky, you couldn’t not here.” With longstanding foils Derek DiCenzo on guitar, Randy Mather on tenor, and Louis Tsamous on drums. Digging into the repertoire of B-3 classics like Jimmy Smith and mingling them with floor-shakers like an extended, shimmering read on Stevie Wonder’s “Sir Duke” and a griding, artfully chopped take on the Booker T and the MGs classic “Green Onions.” I barely stopped moving for two sets. 
Algiers, Rumba Cafe
  • John Paul Keith, Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, Cleveland, 08/27/2021 – One of my favorite songwriters I completely owe Anne for turning me onto. We’ve bemoaned for years Memphis staple John Paul Keith hadn’t played Ohio since we’ve been fans, so as soon as they announced he’d be playing the outdoor pavilion of the Rock Hall in one of our favorite cities, touring to promote his best album yet, Rhythm of the City, it felt like a no-brainer. Those songs with a tight four-piece band of bass, drums, and keys, sparkled in the summer night air. 
  • Big Sandy and the Fly-Rite Boys, Natalie’s Grandview, 09/08/2021 – One of my favorite voices of all time, seeing Big Sandy after a few years away (though his appearances on Stellar Shows’ livestreams, often introducing video clips, were a pandemic delight) was special. My day job friend and mentor, Cindy Jackson, was retiring and doing a Columbus victory lap; CJ’s an even bigger roots rock fiend than I am, so this show lining up with her appearance felt like serendipity. Anne and I took her out to this show, and she loved it as expected – that voice in duet with Ashley Kingman’s guitar (with thanks to longtime pal Jeff Passifume for the amps in the backline) and the bouncing, supple rhythm section of Kevin Stewart’s singing bass and sweet harmonies and Frankie Hernandez’s classic big beat, undiminished by some time away. Everything brought a heaping dose of fire and gratitude like watching a prize fighter bound off the mat again and again, through a series of swinging classics, leaving some space for the dark ballads he doesn’t get enough credit for, with a centerpiece of two Freddie Fender covers that had me crying. Throughout this list, always an exercise in memory and gratitude for me, I’m reminded again that the magic is being in a room with people, sharing all of this with people you love. 
  • Algiers with Zen Mother, Rumba Café, 09/17/2021 – Another delayed show I was on the second it was rescheduled. The last time I saw Algiers, with a substitute bass player, at Big Ears, is still one of the best rock shows I’ve ever seen and this trip to Rumba lived up to those nostalgic expectations. Songs like “There Is No Year” and “Walk Like a Panther” shifted and roared, textures sliced through the air, leaving a lingering impression before being subsumed in waves of pummeling sound. The magpie nature of all good rock and roll, focused like a laser beam. Attention also should be paid to Zen Mother, the power trio that merged the powerful crunch of doom metal with the delicate intimacy of the Cure; I walked in knowing nothing about the opener and walked out singing their praises to everyone. 
Mark Lomax Trio, Short North Stage
  • John Luther Adams’ “Inuksuit”, VIVO Music Festival, Schiller Park, 09/18/2021 – Over the last few years, a couple organizations have done crucial work to fill in one of the few genre gaps I groused about in Columbus for a while: new music/contemporary classical. One is the Johnstone Fund, who show up right after, and the other is the VIVO festival. I was only able to hit one VIVO offering this year, but it summed up so much of what I love about Columbus. Adams’ “Inuksuit” composition, played throughout Schiller Park, around the stage where Actors’ Theatre stages their plays, the pond, wandering through areas close and far, with good friends I’d barely seen since the lockdown started, on a sunny day, and soaking in these harmonies and revealed textures I missed my first trip through this expansive composition at IJAMS as part of Big Ears. 
  • Mark Lomax Trio with Scott Woods, Short North Stage, 09/21/2021 – One of my favorite composers, Mark Lomax II, had touring cut short on his magnum opus The 400 (which I’ve raved about repeatedly here) but never one to be dormant for long, he reintroduced one of my favorite series, The Johnstone Fund For New Music at Short North Stage, with a brand new composition played by his longstanding trio of Dean Hulett on bass and Eddie Bayard on tenor and words from longtime collaborator Scott Woods. “In Search of a City” was exactly the kind of no-easy-answers reckoning we need, especially in a city that too-often prizes growth at the expense of people. 
Drive By Truckers, Newport Music Hall
  • Drive By Truckers, Newport, 10/14/2021 – For over 20 years, DBT have exemplified that sense of communal, going-to-church catharsis I’ve always been drawn to in a rock show. When Anne and I first met and were comparing shows we’ve both been at, they were one of the first names to arise. While my attention drifted for a few years, they won me back in full effect with their records since American Band. This 27-song, sweat-drenched classic rock and soul revue hit every era of their career, and reaffirmed the joy of being back with other people, of shouting along even when the songs are confronting an ugly truth. Patterson Hood, arms outstretched, introducing “Let There Be Rock” as “This is a song about how rock and roll saved my life, and every word of it is true,” always feels like a call to prayer and I really, really needed it this time. 
  • Arooj Aftab and the Vulture Prince Ensemble, Wexner Center, 10/16/2021 – I raved about Arooj Aftab’s new record Vulture Prince here a couple times, and in a preview of this show I wrote for Pencilstorm, and it’s still a piece of surprising, intoxicating beauty and mystery that’s still revealing secrets months after my first hearing. I confess I was a little disappointed when I saw the band in question was just Aftab and the great Gyan Riley on guitar, but within a few minutes any qualms or worries I’d think something was missing. This was an hour of hypnotic rapture I’m already hungry to see again (at Big Ears unless something goes wrong).
Chuck Prophet and the Mission Express, Natalie’s Grandview
  • Chuck Prophet and the Mission Express, Natalie’s Grandview, 10/21/2021 – My and Anne’s last trip to Natalie’s Grandview before lockdown was a solo Chuck Prophet show where he debuted a handful of songs from his then-forthcoming The Land That Time Forgot and teased a full-band return in the Spring. That show got delayed a few times, but he finally made good in October to a crowd that was more than ready for it. That sense of gratitude I mention a few times over the course of this list is always present in Prophet’s work, especially live, and it was overflowing this time. The band stretching some of the songs into extended guitar and keys showcases with barely a hint of wanking; at other times, stripping it down to the simplest of melodies that would break your heart and turns of phrase that could remind you how beautiful and fucked up life is. A masterclass in how much there still is in the form of a five-piece band turned up and tuned in. 
  • Hayes Carll, Skully’s, 11/11/2021 – One of my favorite songwriters since seeing at Twangfest 13 or 14 years ago but Anne and I hadn’t caught Carll since 2011 in Cleveland (I kind of got off the bus with Lovers and Leavers but I’ve come back around). All of that charm and empathy, and diamond-hard and pretty hooks, were in abundance at this Skully’s show where everything good about the venue (the sightlines, the sound) was in fine fetter and everything not so good (the bar service, the tendency to sell the entire capacity of the building instead of just the room with the stage) was ameliorated or kept at bay. Carll’s new songs, including “Nice Things” and “You Get It All” stood up well against classics like “KMAG YOYO” and “Drunken Poet’s Dream.” That conversational sway and disarming smile left me grinning like an idiot and talking about it with Anne and others hours, even days later. 
  • Marc Ribot, Wexner Center, 11/14/2021 – My favorite guitar player, and the subject of not only one of my favorite interviews but one people kept coming up and talking to me about, did not disappoint in a magical solo show at the Wexner’s Mershon Auditorium. Digging deep into standards – “Someone to Watch Over Me”, “Stella by Starlight” – and originals like “Maple Leaf Rage,” stitched together into one continuum of song. 
  • The Randys, Dick’s Den, 12/11/2021 and other dates – If you can’t find some joy in the Randys, I question your capacity to find it anywhere. With a handful of originals sprinkled in, their perfectly chosen mix of classic pop, honky-tonk, and R&B covers, sung beautifully and played with the gleeful abandon of spinning tops and the dazzling precision of vintage clockwork by original four members Brian Jones, Jon Beard, Canaan Faulkner, and David Vaubel, gained a little chaos-theory looseness when they added Derek Dicenzo without sacrificing an ounce of the beauty that keeps us all coming. One of the first shows Anne and I caught was two sets of them playing outdoors to benefit my neighborhood nonprofit the Clintonville Resource Center, one of the last shows I saw before writing this was their annual Christmas show, and they’ve never let me down, never played a gig I fail to see at least one old friend I was overjoyed to dance with. 

Categories
"Hey, Fred!" live music

Things I’ve Been Digging – 02/08/2021

Gretchen Peters and Barry Walsh, taken from the stream and edited

Zeppelin Productions Tribute to Natalie’s

Unlike most of what I write about, this is still up through February 28. Donate and watch here: https://nataliesgrandview.com/events/zeppelin-productions-benefit-for-natalies/

I unabashedly want every venue to make it through to the other side of this. I want the places in my neighborhood that are clubhouses for other musicians, for loudmouths like me, where I’m likely to randomly stop in and discover something thrilling, like Dick’s Den and Ace of Cups to still welcome us all with a heavy pour and friendly faces. I want the places that make me feel old and bring stuff that’s setting kids’ hair on fire to keep giving us all hell – Cafe Bourbon Street, No Place Gallery (give to their fundraiser to relocate), all the house shows.

But it’s no secret there’s a special place in my heart for the Natalie’s family, Natalie and Charlie Jackson, but also their fantastic staff. As soon as they opened the first location in Worthington, this was a model of venue we just didn’t have in Columbus: the closest comparisons were to City Winery (at the time only in NYC) or the Jazz Standard, where sound and the listening environment were given the same kind of care as excellent food and service. 

And within six months, it became apparent we were on the roadmap of acts that hadn’t come to town since Dan Dougan’s Little Brothers closed: Big Sandy, Robbie Fulks, Scott Miller, Barrence Whitfield. Artists raved about it to other people. Soon, they established synchronicity with another booker I’ve talked about as the only reason Columbus is such a strong market for the kind of storytelling roots music I love: Alec Wightman and his Zeppelin Productions.

I’d follow what Wightman books anywhere, and I have, through the uncomfortably tight Columbus Music Hall to the booming Mannerchor, dancing with ghosts in the Valleydale Ballroom, all some of the best shows I’ve seen anywhere, in any city. But there was a unique and comfortable magic when he started bringing things to Natalie’s, even when I had to be on my game to ensure I wasn’t shut out of a seat.

Natalie’s was also hit harder than many venues because the pandemic came only a few months after they expanded into a second, larger, more flexible location. And while there were a few new-venue jitters, seeing a Zeppelin show – Chuck Prophet solo acoustic – early in 2020 made me hungry to watch this venue grow into the same kind of love I have for their Worthington room.

The pivot to live streams has been well-done in this climate, keeping the high sound and production values standards we know and love from their venues. And it speaks to the sterling reputation of both booker and room that Zeppelin assembled a who’s who of towering figures in roots rock and Americana to donate a short video to help out Natalie’s. 

These songs usually came accompanied with sweet words about the space. Many artists – including Tom Russell, who started Alec Wightman booking shows – brought brand new work. Artists did huge hits: Kevin Welch with a song he wrote for Chris Stapleton in a stripped-down, tough, and lovely version. Artists known for their high energy rocking, like Sarah Borges and Rosie Flores, brought more nuanced, shaded sides of their personae.

A couple of artists brought gleeful, surprising covers. Chuck Prophet and Stephanie Finch did “The Little Black Egg,” known to most music fans for its inclusion on Nuggets but with extra resonance as Ohio was one of the few markets it was a real hit. Ward Hayden and the Outliers romped through a joyful, winking version of Ernest Tubb’s “Thanks a Lot.”

And it’s maybe not surprising the performance reverberating in my bones a couple days later as I write this was by Bruce Robison and Kelly Willis. They did Robison’s song “Lifeline” off their first duo record, Cheaters’ Game.

Bruce Robison and Kelly Willis, taken from stream and edited

 As soon as I heard it, it was one of my favorite songs in a catalog packed with contenders. It’s prime Robison, a story song with enough left unsaid for magic to get in, about the ways we connect, like it or not – “There was a crackdown in the street tonight: the stars and the boys ended up in a fight. One step over the line, he says that his Daddy knows mine.” The ways we hunger to connect, “True love comes in the dark, by the rocks and the trees and the rocks in the dark.” The ways we fail to connect, studded with indelible images, “She used to curl up like the steam from a train.”

The taunting darkness as the last verse ends and the final chorus opens were what stuck with me, the tricky balancing act of hope as an act of survival. The way Robison and Willis sing “So damn hard to find…” with a delicate enjambment change the meaning into “Find you” then repeat “Find you” until the previous line almost falls away, getting louder and more powerful, no longer “Find a little lifeline but “Find you a little lifeline – a little bit of hope. In the deep, dark night, need a little bit of rope.” None of us can wholly save each other, and we can’t save ourselves alone, but we can all provide a little rope, in one way or another. 

Thank you, Natalie and Charlie and Alec – and Bruce Robison and Kelly Willis and all the other artists – for reminding me of that. I hope my small contribution added to that hope.

From left: Joe Lovano, Tyshawn Sorey, Bill Frisell. Taken from stream and edited

Tyshawn Sorey/Joe Lovano/Bill Frisell at the Village Vanguard

I’ve waxed rhapsodic about the live streams coming from the legendary Vanguard before, but this weekend’s performance exceeded even my outsized expectations.

I discovered tenor saxophonist Joe Lovano and guitarist Bill Frisell when I was in High School, a solid 15 years into their active careers. They hit creative strides – Lovano on Blue Note Records and Frisell with Nonesuch, as leaders – that period. My burgeoning love for their work led me to the first time I ever heard the drummer Paul Motian: a trio record in this same location that came out a couple of years earlier when I was 15.

This trio date at the Vanguard links these two giants with one of the brightest lights in jazz and chamber music on drums. Tyshawn Sorey’s playing carries the torch of Motian along with a hundred other influences he distills into something fresh, astonishing, and unmistakable. 

The same childhood friend who hipped me to Frisell, Mike Gamble, turned me onto Sorey right after college. I was an immense, drooling fan – anyone who’s read my work has seen him dot year-end lists in almost any year I managed to overlap an NYC trip with a performance of his: Fieldwork at the old Jazz Gallery with Gamble and our other High School buddy, poet Dave Gibbs; Paradoxical Frog at Cornelia Street; as a leader at the Vanguard.

This set vibrated with the spacious, organic magic that’s a trademark of these players. I frequently have a more challenging time paying attention to a live stream than being there in the room – too many distractions – this set had the opposite effect: I couldn’t pay attention to anything else except to write some notes down.

Moments that left my jaw agape, and me gasping came in torrents and also with the perfect, mesmerizing placement of a night’s sky full of stars. Sorey hitting three notes on the vibes, playing off Frisell’s comping, between some skittering, delicate and intense cymbal work, changed the whole texture of Lovano’s dark, lush melody. An unaccompanied Lovano rolling around a theme to amplify the right textures until the band comes in with a clatter and the tune turns into a tightrope knife dance.

A breathtaking set as good as I’ve ever seen anywhere, and something that makes me lucky for the few pleasures we have in these times, and so fortunate people make art despite it all.

Categories
Best Of live music

Best of 2020 – Live Music, Sometimes Virtual

In this fucked-up year, I was lucky enough to see 35 things before it shut down in early March, in four cities. So I was trying to make good on my promise of excitement! And I still tried, even when it felt like just sitting around my house.

Kris Davis’ Diatom Ribbons, Sultan Room

Live:

  • Brett Burleson Quartet (01/04/2020, Dick’s Den) – It’s not always the first show of the year but Burleson’s annual birthday show is a burst of heat early in January that feels like a starting pistol and an invocation to call forth the spirit of a good damn year. This one in particular, at the end of a marathon also celebrating my friend Crystal’s birthday in the little suburb I grew up, and saying goodbye to college standby The Library with some of Anne’s best friends (including the owner Cricket who was selling it), the two sets I caught here were exactly what I needed. Seeing Burleson with a second guitar player is always a rare treat, and his duets with Josh Hindmarsh over a sizzling rhythm section were some of the most beautiful Jim Hall-style melodic guitar fireworks I could have hoped for.
  • Ryan Truesdell’s Tribute to Bob Brookmeyer (01/08/2020, Jazz Standard, NYC) – I wrote about this at some length earlier but this tribute/memorial birthday party to one of the great arrangers (and teachers, my friend Mike still talks about Brookmeyer with massive fondness) summed up the kind of warm feeling of being at an honest-to-god hang. A feeling I’ve gotten more at NYC jazz clubs than anywhere else in the world, and especially at the (RIP) Jazz Standard, a club that always tried harder than it had to and delivered in spades.
  • Winter Jazzfest (01/10/2020 and 01/11/2020, Various Venues, NYC) – For over a decade, WJF has lived up to its promise of giving out of town bookers (here for APAP) and adventurous locals a concentrated look at one of the greatest, most vibrant scenes in the world. It’s expanded to bring in Chicago and London and Brussels and hit all the major genres without feeling like it’s pandering or diluting. Catherine Russell raising her eyebrow at Steven Bernstein on the Le Poisson Rouge stage. Philip Cohran’s sons in Hypnotic Brass Ensemble tearing SOBs apart. Two old friends hugging each other in front of me during Makaya McCraven’s set and the musicians on stage in awe of their bandmates. A marathon for poet Steve Dalachinsky (one of my inspirations, reminding me how often I’d see him around shows). Every time I go, about every other year, I want to go every year.
  • Secret Planet Showcase (01/11/2020, Drom, NYC) – A punky, world music party in one of my favorite clubs (co-thrown by another of my favorite bars, Barbes). I always leave this sore and sweaty. This year was exceptional, with Daptone horn meister Cochemea leading a frenzied band of almost all percussionists, Sunny Jain from Red Baraat’s rippling spaghetti western tuba funk, the lilting melodies and beguiling rhythm of Alba and The Lions. Magic front to back.
Rock Potluck, Ace of Cups
  • Sarah Hennies and Mara Baldwin (01/12/2020, National Sawdust, NYC) – Sarah Hennies, long one of my favorite percussionists and composers, had a hell of a year with a couple of her finest records and what felt like new performances every time I turned around. This collaboration with Mara Baldwin, a violin quartet led by Anna Roberts-Gevalt, with sculptures inspired by Shaker furniture transported me and made a deep impression in a long day of magic that just kept getting better (I’d already seen the Molly Lieber and Eleanor Smith dance piece, the Rachel Harrison retro at the Whitney, and Simon Stone’s Medea with only a break for dinner at St Anselm, and that was all Sunday). 
  • Kris Davis’ Diatom Ribbons (01/12/2020, Sultan Room, NYC) – Pianist Kris Davis is a recurring presence on these lists. She gets better and better. This live production of one of my favorite records of last year was a kaleidoscopic explosion with one of the tightest, most surprising bands I’ve ever seen – including Val Jeanty on turntables and electronics, Terri Lyne Carrington on drums, Tony Malaby on tenor – in my first trip to the tight, sweaty back room of this Middle Eastern restaurant. I got to end this trip on the highest of high notes, with grooves and crackling melody dancing around my head all the way through a nightcap and a fitful sleep before the next morning’s flight.
  • Final Rock Potluck (01/18/2020, Ace of Cups) – Bobby Miller’s given me a lot of my favorite moments in Columbus music – 4th and 4th Fest, Megacity Music Marathon, the last few years of Ace of Cups booking – but maybe his most enduring impact on this town we both love is (with Shane Sweeney in the first couple years) the importing and localizing of the great Dallas tradition as the Rock Potluck. One night only conglomerations of musicians making sparks fly unlike what we’d expect from their own bands. I was still fighting fatigue- and the kind of wet, shitty day January specializes in –  but Anne and I dragged ourselves down for the last few sets of this…and Oh My God. There was so much burbling joy in this room. Bob Starker took a sax solo behind Marcy Mays on a take on the Fleetwood Mac-via-Judas Priest chestnut “The Green Manalishi,” one of the women from Snarls launching into Blink 182’s “All The Small Things” and watching new songs come out of almost thin air. We all left with some of the best memories of this tradition that will be sorely missed.
Raphael Saadiq, Old Forester’s Parishtown Hall
  • Chuck Prophet (01/28/2020, Natalie’s Grandview) – Any of us who love touring music have at least a couple of stories of artists who got pushed back more than once. Alec Wightman booked Prophet’s full band, The Mission Express, in the hopes we’d get our shit together and had to cancel twice as COVID raged. But we were lucky to get the rare solo acoustic version. Classics like “You Could Make a Doubter Out of Jesus” and “Would You Love Me”, newer songs like “High as Johnny Thunders” and “Bad Year For Rock and Roll” co-existed in a set that felt like a journey. And the memory that stuck most with me is the first time I heard the song that most deeply imprinted this year for me, off Prophet’s new record, still a few months out, “Willie and Nill.” A perfect example of the kind of empathic, hard luck stories Prophet writes better than anyone, “Nilli said, ‘I had a body once, Willie you have no idea. I could make a grown man bark all night – anytime, anywhere.’ Willie said, ‘I had a lion’s mane. Now I sing at the top of my lungs till the neighbors get their broomsticks out and the cops all sing along.’”
  • Physical Boys (02/15/2020, Kaiju, Louisville) – The centerpiece of this Valentine’s Day weekend trip to Louisville – that had me miss the Theatre roundtable awards back home – didn’t disappoint but there’s a special joy getting to see something completely new. One of my favorite music rooms, Kaiju, hosted a newish Louisville band Physical Boys who played a beautiful, intoxicating mix of Stiff Records’ sharp jangle and Afghan Whigs operatic sleaze.
  • Raphael Saadiq with Jamila Woods (02/17/2020, Old Forester’s Parishtown Hall, Louisville) – Raphael Saadiq followed his darkest, most personal album with a stripped-down, muscular tour that was unlike any other time I’d ever seen him. Great venue, killer sightlines, fantastic sound. My only regret was missing most of the excellent (from what I caught) Jamila Woods set.
Bria Skonberg and Byron Stripling with Columbus Jazz Orchestra, Southern Theater
  • Bearthoven (02/18/2020, Short North Stage) – The Johnstone Fund has brought more new music (contemporary classical, whatever you want to call it) in the last few years than any earlier time I remember, filling a gap I sorely missed in our musical scene. This return visit from NYC trio – piano, bass, drums – Bearthoven paired a phenomenal new Sarah Hennies (see above) composition with the bright propulsion of a Michael Gordon premiere.
  • Radioactivity with Vacation and Good Shade (02/19/2020, Ace of Cups) – It had been too long since I caught Radioactivity’s spiky brand of angular Texas punk and this three-band bill reaffirmed my faith in catchy, sweaty rock and roll.
  • Columbus Jazz Orchestra featuring Bria Skonberg (02/23/2020, Southern Theater) – I don’t keep up with the CJO as much as I should but this unseasonably sunny Sunday matinee was a shot of pure light in my veins with the group having a ball alongside guest singer and trumpeter Skonberg on great rep including Leonard Cohen’s “Dance Me to the End of Love” and Cole Porter’s “It’s All Right With Me.”
  • Reigning Sound with Venus Flytraps, Bloodshot Bill, and Alarm Clocks (03/06/2020, Beachland Ballroom, Cleveland) – The last trip out of town for some culture before this all went south (well, “as,” the weekend we were up there the first confirmed Ohio cases of COVID were diagnosed in Cleveland. A reunion tour of the original Reigning Sound lineup celebrating both my favorite rock club in the country and one of my favorite record labels, Norton, was everything I want in rock and roll.
  • Amy Lavere and Will Sexton (03/10/2020, Natalie’s Coal-Fired Pizza) – The last local show before everything went to hell  – one of my favorite songwriters, Lavere, backed by her longtime partner (whose songs are coming into their own on his terrific new record this year). Their tour was shortly canceled, but I was thankful for this last glimpse before locking down.

Online:

It was never like being in a room with sweaty strangers, but the proliferation of livestreams and creative pivoting made me feel a little more connected and a little less alone. Favorites of the couple hundred shows I checked in with.

For the first few months of lockdown, Living Music With Nadia Sirota was a balm. One of my favorite violists and a key locus in the new music scene hosted a delightful show once or twice a week, bringing three or more of her pals together – from Claire Chase to Missy Mazzoli, Shilpa Ray to Nathalie Joachim, Judd Greenstein to Ted Hearne – for a taste of what they were doing and a taste of camaraderie I needed even from a remove.

Goner Records simultaneously made me miss Memphis more than ever but gave me a dose of their freewheeling spirit and impeccable taste. Their online translation of Gonerfest was the best streaming version of a festival this year, simultaneously recognizing the international spirit that makes the festival so successful and making us feel like we’re surrounded by our best friends.

Another dose of Memphis came from a weekly shot of John Paul Keith, turning the same skills he uses to keep audiences spellbound as a fine singer, a great guitarist and songwriter, and a charming raconteur toward the camera instead of a barroom. Keith’s jukebox-like memory for songs and artists leads him through delightful anecdotes and a real friendship with people logging in week after week. There was more than one exhausting Monday where hearing JPK say “Hey, Lydia,” brightened me right up – and I don’t even know Lydia.

The north flip-side of those great JPK shows came with Jesse Malin’s Fine Art of Self Distancing, alternately playing solo and his band, from his bars Berlin and Bowery Electric. Malin also ran – with Diane Gentile and others – translations of his fun tribute shows (to Johnny Thunders and The Cramps). Beyond his solid songs, just like Sirota and Keith, he understood and demonstrated what we needed most was fellowship.

Locally, Natalie’s led the way in outdoor shows and now streams, keeping up with their high standards for sound and sight. One of my favorite rooms in town that I dearly hope makes it through this. Ace of Cups got a late start, but I felt very safe on their patio with the precautions they’ve taken and the first of their streams I caught sounded great. 

Jazz clubs in New York have already noted one fallen (Jazz Standard) and are pivoting with great alacrity. Small’s Live and Jazz Gallery are both crushing it with regular, killing performances and Jazz Gallery adds conversations, happy hours, and dance parties. The legendary Village Vanguard is also putting out great sounding, great looking shows by the kind of giants who’d normally be playing to packed houses.

There are still more great performances than I can fit in and more to love than I have time for. I just hope most of these rooms I love make it to the other side and some assistance is forthcoming.

Categories
live music

Chuck Prophet – Natalie’s Grandview, 01/28/2020

Chuck Prophet, Natalie’s Grandview

One of San Francisco’s great pop bards, Chuck Prophet, slid into town through the thick of our late-January malaise to turn the new, slightly larger Natalie’s into a Chinese lantern, illuminated by his complicated, sweet, melancholy light.

Best known as a blistering guitarist and an undersung bandleader, Prophet left his crack band, The Mission Express, at home. Prophet arrived wearing a suit and his troubadour hat, winking at the classic beatnik uniform and cutting down any accusations of self-seriousness. He also made use of an amp and two mics, one for effects, which felt like a poke at the purity and faux-authenticity fetishized by a certain stripe of Americana fan. 

But his primary weapon was that supple, sneaky voice, and one acoustic; toward the end of the night, Prophet said, “I played Oklahoma City a while ago for the first time. Woody Guthrie was from Oklahoma and his guitar killed fascists. This…” holding it up for inspection, “Is harmless.”

Prophet combines a soaked-in-history love of music with the same molten, encompassing love of people in all our fucked-up-ness. Every time he hits the stage, it’s a conversation.  That same sensibility infuses his eye as a writer. The best of the new songs, a story about a couple in “an SRO on Polk Street,” living for the moment when they turn Metallica up so loud the neighbors complain and they sing “Love me like I want to be loved,” found a melancholy sweetness in these two people drawn with ample spaces and a fine pen.

That vein of clear-eyed sweetness traced from the characters from No Other Love classic “Storm Across the Sea” through the shambling chin-up narrator exhorting the world to “Wish Me Luck.” That vulnerability reminds us why “You could make a doubter out of Jesus,” works as an all-time killer pickup line and saves “Would You Love Me” off Soap and Water from a watery, syrupy death in lesser hands.

Prophet also conjures barbed irony – sometimes seemingly lost on part of the audience. The grim, acidic parallel “Nixonland” plays with big, major chords to milk applause like a gladiatorial match asking the audience “live or die.” But his sweet spot is a touch of mourning for a monoculture gone with a knowing smile that it was never as good as people like to remember: the soaring chorus of the new song “High as Johnny Thunders;” the final encore of perhaps his final song, “Willie Mays is Up at Bat” remembering the world of his youth where Bill Graham and Jim Jones rubbed elbows, maybe the best center fielder of the game was walking up to the plate, but still “Nobody knows who’ll make it home tonight.”

Prophet’s refined the lessons of his life and stands as a shining example that getting older doesn’t have to make you exhausted and small. Time changes everything but it doesn’t have to make any of us cruel or sick. That middle of the week, unvarnished, acoustic performance reminded us of the power of song and the power of empathy.